How to measure leadership development: metrics that prove impact

Knowing how to measure leadership development comes down to one question: are leaders behaving differently and is the business better for it? Set a baseline before the programme starts, track behaviour change through the people leaders work with, then connect that change to team and business results over time.
Chief executive officers (CEOs) rank skill and leadership development among their top three workforce priorities for 2026 (The Conference Board, January 2026). Employers also report a 22 percentage-point rise in the importance of leadership and social influence as a core skill (World Economic Forum, January 2025). When leadership is a board-level priority, a satisfaction survey is no longer enough evidence.
Why is leadership development hard to measure?
Leadership development is hard to measure because its results arrive late and through other people. A leader's new habits show up first in their team. Engagement and retention follow, and business numbers move later still. Measuring only at the last session misses most of that chain.
Context also shapes results. A 2025 study in the International Journal of Training and Development followed 20 leaders and 323 of their employees before and after a leadership programme. Real improvement in the behaviour the programme taught, supporting employees' needs, came only when leaders were motivated for their own reasons and interacted frequently with their team. Leaders on the same programme reached change by different routes.
A 2025 National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) working paper on three large firms found that middle managers who engage with their employees and emphasise their development are associated with significantly higher participation in training. Those differences in managers also influenced employee performance and absenteeism. Measurement has to look at the environment around the leader, not just the leader.
How to measure leadership development with the Kirkpatrick Model
A widely used way to measure leadership development is the four levels of the Kirkpatrick Model: reaction, learning, behaviour and results. Each level answers a different question, and only the last two show real change. CoachHub's guide to measuring the return on investment (ROI) of corporate learning and development explains the model and when to add an ROI calculation.
The table below shows what each level tells you in a leadership programme.
| Level | What it shows | Example metrics | When to measure |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Reaction | Whether leaders found the programme relevant | Session ratings, Net Promoter Score (NPS), attendance | During and just after |
| 2. Learning | Whether knowledge and self-awareness grew | Assessments, goal clarity, self-ratings | End of each phase |
| 3. Behaviour | Whether leaders act differently at work | Direct report and peer ratings, goal attainment | Repeatedly, for many months after the programme |
| 4. Results | Whether teams and the business improved | Team engagement, retention, internal promotions, strategic key performance indicators (KPIs) | Long after the programme; promotions can take a few years (SHRM) |
Source: CoachHub, based on the Kirkpatrick Model and Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) guidance (June 2025).
Levels 1 and 2 are easy to collect and easy to overvalue. SHRM advises building data collection into the programme from the start, using performance data or 360-degree assessments rather than treating evaluation as an afterthought.
Which metrics prove leadership development is working?
The metrics that prove impact combine leading and lagging indicators. Leading indicators are early behavioural signals, such as faster decisions or better ratings from direct reports. Lagging indicators follow later, such as team engagement, retention, internal promotions and progress on strategic KPIs. Tracking both lets you show early movement before the business results arrive.
Start with the team. Managers account for 70% of the variance in team engagement, according to Gallup (July 2026). That makes the engagement of a leader's team one of the most direct results you can track. Manager engagement itself has fallen nine percentage points since 2022, to 22% globally in 2025, so the people you are measuring are under strain too.
Retention is the next lagging indicator. US employers recorded 3.1 million quits in August 2026, a quits rate of 1.9% (Bureau of Labor Statistics, September 2026). Compare quit rates in teams whose leaders took part with a baseline or a comparison group, rather than with the national figure alone.
For more ideas on turning goals into indicators, see CoachHub's guide to defining metrics and KPIs to measure the effectiveness of coaching.
How do you measure the success of a leadership development programme?
To measure the success of a leadership development programme, tie it to one business priority and record a baseline. Then ask the people around each leader whether behaviour has changed and compare with a cohort that has not started yet. A comparison group is what lets you credit the change to the programme rather than to the market.
- Name the business priority. Choose the outcome the programme should move, such as retention in a critical function or faster execution of a strategic plan. Then write each leader's leadership development goals as behaviours that move it.
- Record a baseline. Capture team engagement, retention and direct report ratings before the first session.
- Measure behaviour through others. Ask direct reports and peers, not only participants, whether leaders act differently.
- Compare groups. A later cohort can act as a comparison group, which makes it easier to link change to the programme.
- Calculate ROI where the numbers allow. SHRM sets out the formula: total tangible benefits minus programme cost, divided by programme cost, multiplied by 100.
A 2025 randomised trial in PLOS One shows what a comparison group reveals over time. Researchers surveyed 439 employees four times over 18 months. Employees whose managers took part reported significantly greater improvement in their managers' feedback behaviour than the waitlist control group, and the improvement kept growing throughout the 18 months.
How does coaching make leadership development measurable?
Coaching makes leadership development measurable because it turns programme goals into individual behaviour goals that are tracked session by session. Each coachee works on specific behaviours in real situations. That progress can be rated by others and linked to team outcomes, instead of being assumed from attendance.
For the basics, see CoachHub's guide to what leadership coaching is. Coaching skills also show up in team numbers you can track: Gallup reports up to 18% higher engagement in the teams of managers trained in coaching and people development (February 2026). Managers who coach well reinforce the work of professional coaches rather than replace it. Global employee engagement fell to 20% in 2025, its lowest level since 2020, at an estimated cost of $10 trillion in lost productivity (Gallup, 2026).
How does CoachHub measure the impact of leadership development?
CoachHub measures impact with its (im)PACT model, which tracks progress across four stages. Prove covers engagement rates, goal attainment and NPS. Associate maps coaching to retention rates, productivity and internal promotions. Connect links it to objectives and key results (OKR) attainment, cross-functional project delivery and leadership bench strength. Transform tracks overall business performance, organisational capability and organisational resilience.
CoachHub Insights™ gives human resources (HR) and learning and development (L&D) teams real-time data on progress in core areas like communication and goal attainment, so programmes can be adjusted while they run.
"CoachHub has more than 3,500 certified coaches across 90+ countries and coaching available in over 80 languages" (CoachHub). If you are building or reviewing a programme, explore how CoachHub designs a coaching-based leadership development programme with measurement built in, from behaviour change to business outcomes.
FAQ
The four levels come from the Kirkpatrick Model: reaction, learning, behaviour and results. Reaction and learning show whether leaders valued the programme and gained insight. Behaviour and results show whether they lead differently and whether teams and the business improved.
Measure leadership skills by how others experience them. Use 360-degree feedback from direct reports and peers before and after development, alongside goal attainment and team engagement. It is one of several leadership development assessments you can use. Self-ratings add context but should not stand alone.
Behaviour change takes time to show. One 2025 randomised trial found managers' behaviour kept improving across a full 18 months, and SHRM notes that promotions can take a few years. Plan to measure for well over a year, not just at the last session.
Subtract total programme cost from total tangible benefits, divide by programme cost and multiply by 100. Tangible benefits often include savings from better retention and from promoting from within.
Leading indicators are early signals that leaders are changing, such as goal progress and direct report ratings. Lagging indicators are the outcomes that follow, such as team engagement or retention.



.avif)



